Editing the Story: Emmy Nominees for Limited or Anthology Series

Aug 22, 2025

Editing in a limited series is a balancing act. The story has a beginning, middle, and end compressed into a handful of episodes, which means pacing isn’t just rhythm — it’s structure. This year’s nominees show how editors shape performances, control tension, and carve clarity from sprawling worlds. Here’s why each deserves the Emmy.

Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story • “Blame It on the Rain” • Netflix
Peggy Tachdjian, ACE, Editor

Peggy Tachdjian has become a Ryan Murphy go-to, with a versatile background ranging from Only Murders in the Building to Ratched, Shrinking, American Horror Story, and more. On Blame It on the Rain, she knits together competing timelines and tonal extremes with precision. Courtroom scenes are clipped sharp; then suddenly she holds the silence — letting the dread sit awkwardly, making us complicit in the lingering horror.

Tachdjian also noted — during a “How I Did It” feature with TheWrap — that her first cut leaned overly serious. Her director, Carl Franklin, encouraged her to lean into the unsettling absurdity: “We decided to loosen up some of the moments, go more to the audience and really have the audience tell us how ridiculous that moment was.”

That tonal tug-of-war — shifting from severity to uncomfortable dark humor — became her editorial signature for the episode and the series at large

The Penguin • “Bliss” • HBO | Max
Andy Keir, Editor

Andy Keir’s work on Bliss is all about mood and atmosphere. Rather than chase frenetic comic-book energy, he lets Gotham fester. Shots hang just a beat too long, creating a rhythm that mirrors Oswald Cobblepot’s rise: slow, deliberate, inevitable.

Keir’s résumé spans Warrior, True Blood, and Armistead Maupin’s Tales of the City, which helps explain his grip on place as character. In Bliss, his edits don’t just cut between people; they cut between Gotham itself, stitching together alleys, boardrooms, and seedy clubs into a single ecosystem.

That’s why the episode feels immersive. You’re not being propelled forward so much as dragged down with the characters. The edit trusts quiet moments, and the payoff is a Gotham that feels less like a set and more like a living, rotting city.

The Penguin • “Cent’anni” • HBO | Max
Meg Reticker, Editor

Meg Reticker takes on the show’s most operatic chapter in Cent’anni. This is where the gangster saga fully reveals itself, and Reticker cuts it with a Godfather’s patience. Long conversations unfold in measured beats, punctuated by sudden violence. The edit leans into inevitability — every cut feels like it’s building to something grim.

Reticker, a veteran of 30 Rock, The Wire, Big Love, and True Detective, excels at rhythm as power play. She knows when to let silence hold, and when to weaponize it. In Cent’anni, her restraint makes the violent bursts land with shattering force.

Our view: this is the Emmy frontrunner. It’s the most overtly “crafted” entry in the field, but never at the expense of story. Reticker’s choices give the episode its heft, transforming a comic-book spin-off into prestige crime drama.

The Penguin • “A Great or Little Thing” • HBO | Max
Henk Van Eeghen, ACE, Editor

Henk Van Eeghen’s episode is the series’ most structurally complex, juggling parallel storylines without losing coherence. What could have felt like narrative sprawl instead reads as elegant interweaving. That’s the invisible labor of an editor with Lost, Watchmen, Fargo, and The Morning Show on his reel.

The tempo is what impresses here. Van Eeghen builds scenes patiently, letting them simmer, then punctuates with sharp, decisive cuts that reframe the stakes. In a Gotham story crowded with players, his edit ensures you never lose the thread.

What it achieves is balance. The episode feels muscular without being bloated, precise without feeling mechanical. It’s not the flashiest of the Penguin submissions, but it may be the most disciplined.

Sirens • “Exile” • Netflix
Catherine Haight, ACE, Editor

Catherine Haight’s Exile is the quiet outlier in the category — and it benefits from that distinction. Where the Gotham entries flex scope, Haight pares back. She leans into intimacy, holding on performance, letting breath and silence dictate rhythm.

Her background on Transparent prepared her for tonal precision. She knows how to capture vulnerability without drowning it in edits. In Sirens, that translates into a style that lets tension creep in slowly, built from what isn’t said as much as what is.

The effect is unsettling. You feel the dread mounting not because the edit calls attention to itself, but because it doesn’t. Haight trusts the audience to stay with stillness. In awards terms, it’s a bold play: in a field of operatic crime sagas, she’s delivering psychological subtlety.

This category isn’t about flash. It’s about control. Peggy Tachdjian turns true-crime spectacle into structured drama. Andy Keir lets Gotham breathe and rot. Meg Reticker crafts operatic inevitability. Henk Van Eeghen keeps sprawl coherent. Catherine Haight builds dread through restraint.

Together, these nominees prove that limited-series editing isn’t just about keeping story moving — it’s about deciding how we feel scene by scene. The Penguin has sheer momentum with three entries, but Sirens and Monsters make strong cases by carving out their own tonal spaces. Editing is where story becomes story, and all five of these nominees deliver.

You May Also Like

How ‘Ted Lasso’ Editors Melissa McCoy and A.J. Catoline Found Season Four in the Cutting Room
How ‘Ted Lasso’ Editors Melissa McCoy and A.J. Catoline Found Season Four in the Cutting Room

The second episode of Ted Lasso’s new season was scripted to end on a gag. Editor A.J. Catoline and director MJ Delaney ended it on Tanya Reynolds staring straight into the lens instead. Catoline and Melissa McCoy, who have cut the show since the pilot, talk about the premiere’s closed door, a head swap for Brett Goldstein, empty seats at the women’s matches and the one shot they asked Jason Sudeikis to leave alone.

What the Crafts Categories Actually Told Us This Emmy Season
What the Crafts Categories Actually Told Us This Emmy Season

The 78th Emmys handed out their Creative Arts trophies over two nights at the Peacock Theater, and by the end of it, three shows had quietly taken over the below-the-line side of the ceremony. None of them were the season’s most-nominated title.

The Latest News
Blackmagic Design Announces DaVinci Resolve 21.1
Blackmagic Design Announces DaVinci Resolve 21.1

Blackmagic Design today announced DaVinci Resolve 21.1, a major new update that introduces AI assistant integration allowing customers to efficiently manage tasks such as organizing media or batch rendering, as well as expanded support for camera formats on the photo page.

What the Crafts Categories Actually Told Us This Emmy Season
What the Crafts Categories Actually Told Us This Emmy Season

The 78th Emmys handed out their Creative Arts trophies over two nights at the Peacock Theater, and by the end of it, three shows had quietly taken over the below-the-line side of the ceremony. None of them were the season's most-nominated title. Apple TV's Widow's...